In general, observers in motion with respect to one another, will detect light from a distant event at different times, or different locations, or both. In Case I, each of three observers will detect the light from a distant flash simultaneously, though at different locations. The Doppler shift in their observed frequencies betrays relative motion with respect to the source, thus each observer is able to agree on the distance from, and time since, their current locations.
crenshaw@teleinc.com 